No Scar?
(a poem by Amy Carmichael)

Amy Carmichael was an Irish Christian whose faith story includes serving the poor of Belfast and the abused of India. I have loved this poem of hers—No Scar?—for more than 20 years, but I have not been able to learn the story of when she wrote it or why. If you know, I’d love it if you’d post a comment.
no scarHast thou no scar?
No hidden scar on foot, or side, or hand?
I hear thee sung as mighty in the land,
I hear them hail thy bright ascendant star,
Hast thou no scar?

Hast thou no wound?
Yet I was wounded by the archers, spent,
Leaned Me against a tree to die, and rent
by ravening beasts that compassed Me, I swooned:
Hast thou no wound?

No wound, no scar?
Yet as the Master shall the servant be,
And, pierced are the feet that follow Me;
But thine are whole: can he have followed far
Who has no wound nor scar?

16 thoughts on “No Scar? </br>(a poem by Amy Carmichael)”

  1. I also found this impactful and did a little research.
    Here is what I found:
    Amy Carmichael was a missionary to orphans in India.
    She suffered much — and bore much eternal fruit.
    Back in the 1920s, Amy rescued hundreds of orphaned children — especially little girls that would be dedicated to Hindu gods for use in sexual temple rituals. By God’s wonderful grace, some had miraculously escaped from such pagan slavery and were led to the Irish “mother” who lovingly cared for each child God sent her.
    In 1931 she prayed, “God, please do with me whatever you want. Do anything that will help me to serve you better.”
    That same day, she fell, suffering fractures that would cripple her for the rest of her life. Not one to be discouraged or bitter when faced with pain or persecution, Amy now had the opportunity to demonstrate God’s faithfulness before a much larger “host” of witnesses. While her growing children had continual freedom to enter her bedroom and share their hearts with their beloved “mother,” she now had the quiet times that allowed her to write books, poems, and letters that were translated and shared around the world.
    “For to you it has been granted on behalf of Christ, not only to believe in Him, but also to suffer for His sake.”
    Philippians 1:29

  2. Melanie,
    Thank you for sharing this touching poem. It certainly gives us things to think about. And thank you, too, Doyle, for sharing what you learned about Amy Carmichael. She surely was one who served in a meaningful way, although I’m sure she kept her wounds and scars close to her heart without making her suffering known. A woman to emulate, because she followed our Savior!

    • I get the feeling from this poem that Amy Carmichael would consider each scar, each sacrifice, each disappointment a badge of honor—because they served as evidence of how closely she walked in the Savior’s footsteps!

  3. Amen! Very powerful. And thanks Doyle for sharing the history behind it. A woman to emulate, is right! Makes me think about how I could be doing so much more to serve others too… how blessed we are to have these saints & their stories who have gone before us…

    • You’re right, Michelle—the Christian community is bigger than whatever church we belong to today. It includes all the saints around the world throughout history. We are not alone! And our stories become part of that tapestry, so that other people can benefit from the lessons we learn.

  4. Hello. Yes, this poem is referred to in Elizabeth Elliot’s, A CHANCE TO DIE – The Life and Legacy of Amy Carmichael; chapter 34. Elizabeth has helped us to know Amy.. Do read this. Amy’s life was LOVE, and I am encouraged by her devotion.

  5. Love the sentiment but must advise readers that the Lord Jesus Christ did NOT “swoon ” theologians use “swoon theory” to explain away the glorious resurrection, and they say Jesus never died but just “swooned”

    • Interesting, Billy. I am not familiar with the “swoon theory.” My sense of Amy Carmichael though, is that she did not intend to suggest that Jesus never died. I interpret her use of the word “swoon” only to convey the drama and pain Jesus experienced. It seems to me that this is in line with the main message of the poem—that as followers of Jesus, we can expect suffering and even death.

  6. I read that Watchman Nee wrote this hymn which was no. 510 in “Christ in Song”. This was stated in the introduction to “My Spiritual Journey” by Watchman Nee. Don’t know who wrote the intro though. After reading this, was surprised to see the song associated with Amy Carmichael.

Comments are closed.